Plug Valve vs Ball Valve - How To Choose

When considering whether to use a plug valve or a ball valve, it's essential to understand that each has unique characteristics tailored to specific applications. Plug valves feature a simple design and provide a tight seal, making them ideal for on/off control in systems with frequent actuation. In contrast, ball valves are known for their durability and ability to maintain a secure closure even after long periods of inactivity.

Plug Valve vs Ball Valve

Figure 1: Plug valve (left) and ball valve (right)

View Details

Plug valves and ball valves are used across various industries to control the flow of liquids and gases. Both have unique features and design differences that make them suitable for different applications. To help determine which type of valve is more suitable for a given application, this article explores the key differences between plug and ball valves, including their design, function, advantages, and disadvantages.

What is a Plug Valve

A plug valve (Figure 1 left) is a quarter-turn valve that uses a tapered or cylindrical plug to control the flow of liquids or gases. The plug rotates within the valve body to open or close the flow path. Plug valves are known for their simple design and ability to provide a tight shutoff, making them a popular choice in various industries, including water treatment, oil and gas production, chemical processing, and pulp and paper manufacturing.

What is a Ball Valve

A ball valve (Figure 1 right) is a quarter-turn valve that uses a ball with a bore to control the flow of liquids or gases. The ball rotates on its axis to open or close the flow path. Ball valves have fast and efficient operation, durability, and a long lifespan. They are used in heating and cooling systems, water distribution, and industrial process cooling.

Plug Valve vs Ball Valve Differences

Plug and ball valves differ in the following aspects:

Operation Principle

Plug Valve Operation

The plug valve consists of a body with either a tapered or parallel seat. A plug fits into this seat. The plug is designed with an opening whose position determines the amount of opening through the valve. These openings in the valve body, known as ports, allow fluid to enter or exit. When the plug is turned 90 degrees, it fully opens or closes the fluid flow. However, despite being a quarter-turn valve, the plug valve is less efficient when compared to ball valves, and they can only function in the fully open or closed position. When the port in the plug is aligned with the inlet and outlet ports, fluid flow continues through the valve. However, a pressure drop occurs through the reduced area of the plug port, which is a disadvantage compared to a ball valve.

Ball Valve Operation

A ball valve is a quarter-turn valve that uses a hollow, perforated, and pivoting ball to control flow. The ball rotates within the valve body to control fluid flow, and its simple design makes it easy to operate and maintain. A valve stem connects to the ball. When the valve stem is turned a quarter-turn, the bore is either open to the flow allowing media to flow through, or closed to prevent media flow.

Sealing Properties

Both plug and ball valves are quarter-turn valves that close and open when their stem is rotated by 90 degrees. These valves are primarily used for shut-off purposes. However, there are a few differences between them.

Plug Valve Sealing

The surface area for sealing in a plug valve is noticeably more significant than that of a ball valve. This results in improved sealing capabilities, necessitating greater operation effort and torque.

Ball Valve Sealing

Ball valves are lighter in weight and easier to operate due to their low torque requirements. The smaller sealing area in these valves may lead to a sealing performance below that of plug valves. However, recent innovations in seal injections and chemical sealing solutions have effectively addressed this issue.

Types

Plug Valve Types

Plug valves are classified based on whether they are lubricated and the shape of their plugs.

• Lubricated plug valves are designed to operate with a lubricant film between the plug and the valve body. This lubrication helps to reduce friction and wear on the plug and body, increasing the valve's operational life and reliability. Lubricated plug valves also offer tighter sealing and improved performance in high-pressure applications.

Non-lubricated plug valves, on the other hand, do not require a lubricant and are typically used in applications where the fluid being controlled is incompatible with the lubricant. Non-lubricated plug valves are also preferred in applications where a lubricant may pose a contamination risk, such as in the food and beverage industry.

• The openings within the plug can have different shapes (like rounded or rectangular).

Ball Valve Types

Ball valves are categorized based on several parameters.

Maintenance

Both plug and ball valves require routine maintenance to ensure optimal performance.

Plug Valve Maintenance

Plug valves are more manageable due to their straightforward design and limited moving components. The plug can be easily removed and cleaned, while accessing the rest of the valve body for cleaning purposes is also simple.

Ball Valve Maintenance

Ball valves present a greater challenge when cleaning. The ball or disc is situated deep inside the valve, making it challenging to access. Over time, the cavity of the ball valve may accumulate debris from the medium, further complicating the cleaning and maintenance process.

Cost

Plug valves offer a more cost-effective operation compared to ball valves. The plug in the plug valve fits snugly under the bushing, which helps to prevent wear and tear on the valve body and plug. Simply replacing the bushing and top seal is sufficient to maintain the valve's function and ensure longevity.

Application

Plug Valve Application

Plug valves are suitable for applications involving abrasive materials, such as sewage, mud, and slurries, due to their increased surface area and unrestricted fluid flow. They ensure a tight seal when handling corrosive substances, and their anti-corrosive properties make them a reliable option for challenging applications.

Ball Valve Application

A ball valve is a popular choice for automation, particularly in industries such as natural gas and crude oil transfer, LNG plants, polymer production, and field gas processing. They are also useful in various industrial environments, including turbine and compressor skids, oil refinery feedstock lines, tank farms, and hydrocarbon processing. Read our ball valve applications article for more details.

Longevity

Plug Valve Longevity

A large surface of the plug valve contacts the medium, increasing the chances of corrosion. Handling more torque also exposes the plug valve to more wear.

Ball Valve Longevity

Ball valves have features that prevent the medium from coming into contact with the disc. The lower torque also reduces wear and tear in the long run. Read our article on ball valves for corrosive media to know more about how to design a ball valve for corrosive environments.

Conclusion

Plug and ball valves regulate fluid flow using a straightforward on or off function or a multipath feature. Take the following into consideration when choosing when to use a ball valve vs a plug valve:

• A plug valve is the best choice for sensitive applications as they offer perfect sealing and a straightforward application structure. Also, they cost less than ball valves. However, they are not as compact as ball valves and cause a pressure drop from inlet to outlet.
• Choose ball valves for large high-pressure applications that require an easier operation. They are easier to use and are more compact than plug valves but with slightly reduced sealing capabilities.

For example, a ball valve would be the better choice for an application that requires regulating fluid flow in a water treatment plant because it allows flow direction changes and can handle high-pressure and temperature applications. A plug valve would be more suitable to regulate fluid flow in a pipeline system involving slurry as it requires less maintenance and allows for a straight fluid flow. However, ball valves are more commonly used for shutoff applications due to their simple and lightweight design and ease of use due to their torque-free operation. Table 1 compares the features of plug valves and ball valves.

Table 1: Plug valve vs ball valve

Feature Plug valve Ball valve Operation principle A plug valve has a plug designed with an opening whose position determines the amount of opening through the valve. These openings in the valve body, known as ports, allow fluid to enter or exit. A ball valve has a hollow, perforated, and pivoting ball to control flow. The ball rotates within the valve body to control fluid flow. Sealing properties More sealing surface area and hence enhanced sealing characteristics but requires greater operation effort and torque. A more manageable operation and lighter weight due to their low torque requirements. The smaller sealing area in these valves may lead to a sealing performance below that of plug valves Types Plug valves are categorized according to whether or not they are lubricated and their plug shape (rounded, rectangular, etc). Ball valves are divided into different groups based on the size and shape of their bores as well as whether the ball floats inside the valve body or is supported on a pivot. Maintenance Easy to clean Difficult to clean as the ball and other parts are situated deep inside the valve. Cost Less costly More costly Application Applications involving abrasive materials, such as sewage, mud, and slurries, A ball valve is a popular choice for automation, particularly in industries such as natural gas and crude oil transfer, LNG plants, polymer production, residential plumbing, and field gas processing. Longevity Less durable More durable

FAQs

Why Choose Plug Valves Over Ball Valves?

Plug valves have a better sealing ability than ball valves because they have a larger sealing surface.

Are Plug Valves Better Than Ball Valves?

Typically, plug valves have a shorter lifespan than ball valves. This is because plug valves have a higher potential to undergo erosion as more fluids come into contact with the cylinder. On the other hand, ball valves have less contact with fluids, require less torque, and have more moving components.

What Is the Difference Between an Eccentric Plug Valve and a Ball Valve?

An eccentric plug valve has a plug-shaped, flow-restricting component that rotates in an eccentric direction, and a ball valve regulates the flow of liquids or gases by using a ball with a bore.

Advantages of a Plug Valve

Primary Sealing

A continuous primary seal results from the interaction of the tapered plug and the tapered body bore. Cast-in ribs behind the body lining concentrate compression of the lining between the ribs and the plug. This assures a full circumferential in-line seal. There is also a full circumferential seal around the plug, both above and below the flow passage. There are no cavities where flow media can accumulate or contaminate.

Easily Adjusted Seal

The three adjustment bolts in the cover and the bottom adjustment bolt work together to assure a maximum sealing capability and an extended service life.

Secondary Seal

In addition to the primary seals, there is a secondary seal system consisting of interacting components. The secondary stem seals, located above the plug, protect against external leakage up to 400°F.

1. The PTFE diaphragm is shaped into an inverted V at its inner circumference. It seals at the cover joint and against the plug shank.

2. To help assure positive sealing and easy adjustment, the PTFE wedge ring fits into the V-formed inner circumference of the PTFE diaphragm. Sealing force is transmitted from the thrust collar (4) through the wedge ring.

3. A metal diaphragm is above the PTFE diaphragm and wedge ring. This metal diaphragm provides metal-to-metal contact at the cover joint. This prevents cold-flow of the PTFE diaphragm. This configuration provides two independent compression seals between the body and the cover. One seal is plastic; the second is metal.

4. On top of the metal diaphragm is a floating thrust collar which acts to assure uniform pressure on all sealing surfaces.

5. Above the cover, on the plug shank of wrench operated valves, is a static eliminator which provides a positive electrical ground between the body and the plug.

6. Three adjusting bolts in the cover impart downward force through the thrust collar (4), to the wedge ring (2), then to the inner leg of the inverted V of the PTFE diaphragm (1). This, together with the opposing force of the plug, provides a pressure assisted seal which is not adversely affected by plug movement. The adjusting bolts also facilitate quick and easy adjustment of in-line sealing.

Featured content:
Pinch Valves for Industrial Applications